By: Yahye S. Bulqaas

Mogadishu (Commentary) — For far too long the 4.5 power-sharing system has retained an explanatory appeal for political analysts preoccupied with making sense of the Somali political turmoil.

Unveiled in 2000 at the Djibouti-sponsored Somali Reconciliation Conference, the power-sharing formula divides Somalis into four major clans and an alliance of clans known as Others.

Since 1960 the presidency has rotated between two clans — Darod and Hawiye. Professor Ahmed Ismail Samatar described this uncodified arrangement as duopoly.

This theory works that if one pays attention to clan identities of Somalia’s successive presidents.

It loses its analytical power if one concentrates on the nature of election outcomes since 2004.

Neither the incumbent President of Somalia Mohamed Abdullahi Mohamed nor his predecessor Hassan Sheikh Mohamud was a favourite candidate in 2017, and 2012, respectively.

Two Somali clans make consequential decisions under the 4.5 power-sharing system.

Arithmetically, each Presidential candidate has a 20% chance to win the Somali Presidency, assuming that only five candidates from the five Somali clans are contesting the post.

The duopoly argument loses sight of substantive political power embedded in Federal Member States.

Hawiye and Darod political classes control four Federal Member States — two for each clan.

Banadir, the seat of the capital is a Hawiye sphere of inclusivity due to the irremediable dispossessions after the collapse of the state in 1991.

Some Darod and Hawiye politicians have struck an informal political deal: keep the capital city in Mogadishu and keep the federal system.

Puntland, the originator of the post-1991 federal system, argues the federal system is the middle path between secessionist impulses and the centralism tendencies.

The argument runs thus: centralism puts the periphery at a disadvantage, empowers dictatorship and results in state collapse; unilateral secession violates territorial, and the political unity of Somalia.

Under the current federal system only three clans wield political power — Darod, Hawiye, and Digil & Mirifle.

Dir and the Fifth Clan (aka Others) do not control a Federal Member States but have a total of 40% voting power during the presidential election.

Voting power does not necessarily equate to substantive political power in the absence of a federated stronghold to fall back on.

Under pressure to sideline the Presidency: Will Prime Minister Roble remember that Mogadishu and Somalia aren’t interchangeable?

The 4.5 power-sharing system pales into insignificance given the seemingly enduring 2/5 (two-fifth) element in Somali politics where political classes from only two clans — Darod and Hawiye — make consequential political decisions.

How does a 40% voting power trump 60% voting power?

The answer could be found in the distinctive political outlooks represented by the political power vested in the capital and the primacy of the federal system.

When the former Somalia Prime Minister Omar Abdirashid Ali Sharmarke, in a Tweet, proposed sidelining the Somali Presidency during electoral talks, he sought to deepen the 2/5 supremacy and expected Prime Minister Mohamed Hussein Roble to fall for the gimmick.

Forming an alliance against the incumbent Somalia President is proving difficult.

He represents a strong state school of thought against the fiefdom-based political supremacy inspired by post-1990 warlords in Somalia.

There is no guarantee that the three other Somali clans — Dir, the Fifth Clan, and Digil & Mirifle — will back a temporary political alliance of two social groups at the expense of 60% of the population; a quantification based on the voting rights under the 4.5 power-sharing system.

Roble is under pressure to maintain the political inequalities that relegate the Fifth Clans to the status of figureheads in the Somali political firmament.

Giving in to the pressure will not only be a betrayal but also a repeat of the political miscalculation committed by United Somali Congress in 1991.

A government based in Mogadishu is vulnerable to the whims of local politicians who can mobilize militias.

This is the lesson from the recent clashes in the capital over the controversial mandate extension for federal institutions. Clan militias operating alongside security forces in Mogadishu bode the end of Somalia as we know it; and its break-up into cantons ruled by born-again warlords.

Politically marginalised Somali social groups are seeking ways to end their status of playing second fiddle to the two dominant clans in Somali politics.

A lot depends on how they respond to the unholy political alliance symbolized by the 2/5 arrangement.

This article first appeared in the © Puntland Post, 2021 and is republished with permission

  1. Pingback: Temp EMail
  2. Pingback: WordPress
  3. Pingback: Beverly Bultron
  4. Pingback: Arie Baisch
  5. Pingback: Lila Lovely BBW
  6. Pingback: MILF Porn
  7. Pingback: buy-domains
  8. Pingback: valentines gift
  9. Pingback: Click Here
  10. Pingback: Click Here
  11. Pingback: Click Here
  12. Pingback: Click Here
  13. Pingback: Click Here
  14. Pingback: Click Here
  15. Pingback: Click Here
  16. Pingback: Click Here
  17. Pingback: Click Here
  18. Pingback: Click Here
  19. Pingback: Click Here
  20. Pingback: Click Here
  21. Pingback: Click Here
  22. Pingback: Click Here
  23. Pingback: Click Here
  24. Pingback: Click Here
  25. Pingback: Click Here
  26. Pingback: Click Here
  27. Pingback: moveit studio
  28. Pingback: no code robotics
  29. Pingback: Click Here
  30. Pingback: Click Here
  31. Pingback: Click Here
  32. Pingback: Click Here
  33. Pingback: Click Here
  34. Pingback: Click Here
  35. Pingback: Click Here
  36. Pingback: Click Here
  37. Pingback: Click Here
  38. Pingback: Click Here
  39. Pingback: Click Here
  40. Pingback: Click Here
  41. Pingback: Click Here
  42. Pingback: Click Here
  43. Pingback: Click Here
  44. Pingback: Click Here
  45. Pingback: Click Here
  46. Pingback: Click Here
  47. Pingback: Click Here
  48. Pingback: Click Here
  49. Pingback: Click Here
  50. Pingback: Click Here
  51. Pingback: Click Here
  52. Pingback: Click Here
  53. Pingback: Click Here
  54. Pingback: Click Here
  55. Pingback: Click Here
  56. Pingback: Click Here
  57. Pingback: Click Here
  58. Pingback: Click Here
  59. Pingback: Click Here
  60. Pingback: Click Here
  61. Pingback: Click Here
  62. Pingback: Click Here
  63. Pingback: Refer and Earn
  64. Pingback: Click Here
  65. Pingback: Click Here
  66. Pingback: Click Here
  67. Pingback: Click Here
  68. Pingback: Click Here
  69. Pingback: Click Here
  70. Pingback: Click Here
  71. Pingback: Click Here
  72. Pingback: Click Here
  73. Pingback: Click Here
  74. Pingback: Click Here
  75. Pingback: buy-domains
  76. Pingback: top startup books
  77. Pingback: formation agents
  78. Pingback: realtor advertise
  79. Pingback: Google reviews
  80. Pingback: 2023 Books
  81. Pingback: search dececased
  82. Pingback: dead people
  83. Pingback: online memorial
  84. Pingback: burial
  85. Pingback: Chirurgie Tunisie
  86. Pingback: Chirurgie Tunisie
  87. Pingback: Schneider Electric
  88. Pingback: Ethical practices
  89. Pingback: Politics
  90. Pingback: FUE
  91. Pingback: Dental Training
  92. Pingback: Welcome Party 2021
  93. Pingback: distance education
  94. Pingback: fue
  95. Pingback: bodytone
  96. Pingback: cage a squat

Comments are closed.

You May Also Like

Despite Trade War, Taiwan Raises Economic Forecast For 2020

The ongoing US-China trade war seems to be impacting everyone, except perhaps
Manny Ramirez in his stint in Taiwan: CC

TTT Interview: Manny Ramirez “baseball royalty”

Manny Ramirez is a baseball superstar.  In an MLB career that lasted

Taiwan-China ties compared to ‘bastard and daddy relationship’ by Han Kuo-Yu

We know that the things are heating up in Taiwan’s political scene

Chinese Troops Struggle With Low Quality Winter Clothing On Indian Border

The People’s Liberation Army (PLA)’s adventurism has started costing it heavily. Actions